Click Here to Join for FREE!  Login 
A Family Outdoor Learning Center

  Search Site
 You Are Here: ..:: Discussions ::..
Your Own Lake Lot  
20 Acres Hunting Land - SOLD
Lake County, Minnesota
Up North
20 Acres Hunting Land - SOLD
Full details
Brainerd Lakes Area Lakeshore
Emily, Minnesota
Ross Lake
Brainerd Lakes Area Lakeshore
Full details

Outdoor Adventure Audio CD - Trout Whisperer
Outdoor Adventure CD
Trout Whisperer

Listen to Sample

Buy Now
 


About Us  

Departments  

Resources  

Outdoor News  

Minnesota | Camping Forum | Fishing Forum | Hunting Forum | Outdoor Photography forum | Nature Forum

Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan Camping forums - Hiking forums - Fishing forums - Hunting forums - Nature forums - Outdoor Photography forum - Join the fun!

Forget Barack Obama and John McCain -Trout Whisperer for President

camping forum | fishing forum | hiking forum | hunting forum | nature photography forum

A great, friendly, place to find tips, get questions answered and to post your thoughts. Give it a try and post a message.

Feel free to post messages on any subject. But be nice, no profanity, no name calling, no commercial posts.

Members -  be sure to check for new pics in the Photo Gallery.

You just need to Register for free and Login to post a message in the forums.

Outdoor Recreation Forum Moderator: 
Buck Anderson

 2008 Totally Stupid Presidential Election Poll  
Who will you vote for in the 2008 Presidential Election?



Submit Survey  View Results

Subject: Was Mark Raveling's Record Bass Illegal?
Prev Next
Please login to post a reply. Not a member? Register now.

Author Messages
BuckUser is Offline
JustNorth Pro
JustNorth Pro
Posts:1101

Send Private Message
10/18/2005 1:27 PM  
I read an interesting article by Glen Schmitt, in the St. Cloud Times, regarding the new Minnesota State record bass. The title of the article was "Don't treat record fish negatively".

Glen had commented, "Is there really any need to create a buzz about whether, or not, or to what extent, Mark Raveling broke the law by transporting his state record largemouth bass in a livewell full of water?".

He went on to discuss the Minnesota regulations and the possible violations that exist. One for transporting a live fish and the other for not draining his livewell after leaving the lake.

The first is to make sure anglers don't catch fish on one lake and release them into another. The latter is to prevent the spread of exotic species such as Eurasian milfoil which already exists in more than 170 lakes and streams.

Glen went on to state that State regulations prohibit the transportation of live fish. Legally everyone is supposed to drain their livewell, buckets, and coolers before they leave the lake. Legally, we're supposed to make sure our catch is dead before we head for home.

Glen's conclusion was that the DNR had no intention of citing Raveling, we should relish the fact that a new State record bass was caught and there is no way negative spin should be applied to this situation. He feels Mark Raveling didn't deserve a ticket and the State record bass should be the story, not how the fish was recognized as such. He goes on to conclude that the DNR could use this situation to reexamine regulations and that maybe it is time to review the policy for recognizing a state-record fish.

What do you think?

Robb "Buck" Anderson
President
JustNorth Outdoors
scumfrogUser is Offline
JustNorth All-Star
JustNorth All-Star
Posts:123
Send Private Message
10/18/2005 1:54 PM  
Ok, doesn't it say some place in the rules of catching and registering a record fish, that it must be alive at weigh in.. I also know that they (D.N.R.) x-ray fish to insure that no one has tampered with the weight, like stuffing sinkers in it. And also fish start loosing weight after they are caught from the stress. It's great that the record was broke (to bad it wasn't me that did it.) he tried to profit from this fish by taking all over and showing it off. It's just to bad for the fish, and us cause now that big bass wont pass on those genes to produce bigger bass.

LET IT GO, SO IT CAN GROW…...

Please login to post a reply. Not a member? Register now.
Forums > Fishing Forums > Fishing forum > Was Mark Raveling's Record Bass Illegal?



ActiveForums 3.7

Message attachments are for uploading a picture to your post. Allowed file types are jpg and gif. Max file size is 600 kb. For help see Frequently Asked Questions.

Bookmark this page, tell your friends, and visit us often. We enjoy your company!

Recent Topics  
motion sickness by trout whisperer :: Ask Trout Whisperer - Pro Guide and Columnist
Replies :: 0
Great question! by RandyMan :: Ask Randy Johnson
Replies :: 2
duck opener by trout whisperer :: Ask Trout Whisperer - Pro Guide and Columnist
Replies :: 2
Help with coyotes and foxes...killing my poultry by tgebers :: Hunting Forum
Replies :: 2
A 25.5 pound Chinook caught by Rita Quisenberry by Jim Blue Max Charters :: Fishing forum
Replies :: 0
She was Soooooooo Blonde. by LAURA :: The Back Room
Replies :: 3
the pinkies are here.....and some coasters by trout whisperer :: Ask Trout Whisperer - Pro Guide and Columnist
Replies :: 0
River Hog Chinook Salmon On The Bite Now! by justnorth :: Fishing forum
Replies :: 0
Warm weather bow hunting tip (your mom was right) by tgebers :: Hunting Forum
Replies :: 5
Happy September by trout whisperer :: Ask Trout Whisperer - Pro Guide and Columnist
Replies :: 0

Recent Posts  

Click to view JNO departments
Outdoors LibraryFishingHuntingCamping and HikingSnow SportsWomen OutdoorsWhat's New at JustNorth Outdoors

Your Friends Aren't JNOs?
Invite them to Join JustNorth Today

About This Site  Site Map  Contact Us  Sample Articles  Join JustNorth  Link to Us  Tell a Friend

Minnesota | Camping Forums | Fishing Forums | Hunting Forums | Nature Forums | Outdoor Photography Forums 

Fully Searchable Forums For Outdoor Enthusiasts

JustNorth Outdoors hunting and fishing discussion forums - Have questions or comments about creating outdoors videos, outdoors photography, hunting, fishing, ice fishing, camping, skiing and snow sports, conservation issues, gear, or politics? Participate in the forums...

Copyright 2008 Jive Media Group LLC. All Rights Reserved.  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement | Advertise With Us
Page generated in 0.312002 seconds.  reduce website downtime | powered byVisit Jive Media Group LLC